Are you capable of holding an online conversation without swearing etc?
Serving Wearside since 2012!

Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

This is the SAFC Forum. You may chat about Sunderland AFC here together with any other footballing matters. Obviously, the Black Cats are the main focus. However, this is basically our football lounge.
Post Reply

Which would have given Sunderland fans more reason to celebrate in party style?

Poll ended at 06 Jun 2019, 16:00

Checkatrade Trophy
10
77%
Promotion
3
23%
 
Total votes: 13

User avatar
Nockya
Local Legend
Local Legend
Posts: 1707
Joined: 17 Jul 2013, 10:36
Location: Downhill

Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by Nockya »

Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

This is a poll about which celebrations would have been better.
We didn't win the cup but promotion is obviously within our grasp now.
So, the question is - which would give Sunderland fans the biggest celebration resulting in the best party?

I am going for the Checkatrade Trophy and the reason is simple, our expectation is promotion and nothing else will do.
Winning a Wembley final since 1973 would have been the cherry on the top of the cake and I reckon the party for that would have been far bigger.
Promotion will pass us by with a much smaller celebration in my opinion but what do you think?



User avatar
Jenky
Local MP
Local MP
Posts: 896
Joined: 20 Jul 2013, 12:23
Location: Southwick

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by Jenky »

You could be right, we all had plans of going down the town on the Monday night but that didn't happen because of the defeat. Had we been in a position like Luton are now we would have possibly had an open-top bus celebration as well. However, I don't think we would have had the street parties like we did in 1973 because the community is not like it was then.

If promotion was a REAL possibility (like Luton's chances) then the Checkatrade Trophy would have given us a massive party. But winning the cup while we are in this position would have still given us better parties. We will get promotion I have no doubt now and we will all just shake hands and that will be that. Therefore the cup would edge it on the celebration scale ;)



User avatar
Sunderland Nut
Freedom of the City
Freedom of the City
Posts: 2738
Joined: 11 Jan 2015, 19:13
Location: Downhill
Top poster of the Month

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by Sunderland Nut »

Tough call but maybe the cup would have given us room for a celebration.



User avatar
Sandy Mackem
Sunderland Supporter
Sunderland Supporter
Posts: 617
Joined: 27 Jul 2013, 05:49
Location: Whitburn

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by Sandy Mackem »

At first this was a no brainier until I read the question properly. If we won the cup then yes I think I would have celebrated like there's no tomorrow. On the day we get promotion the Sunderland supporters will celebrate though not as much as if we brought the cup back.



User avatar
Bus Driver
Local MP
Local MP
Posts: 895
Joined: 11 Aug 2013, 18:09
Location: Pennywell

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by Bus Driver »

Considering the celebrations in Trafalgar Square and London in general I would say the Checkatrade Trophy already won it :lol:
Sunderland fans have already had the celebrations and the forthcoming promotion party won't be anywhere near that.






User avatar
Cheesy Chips
Active Citizen
Active Citizen
Posts: 85
Joined: 24 Nov 2013, 09:15
Location: Pennywell

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by Cheesy Chips »

Had our cheesy chips on Wembley Way and I still haven't recovered 8-)



User avatar
Nockya
Local Legend
Local Legend
Posts: 1707
Joined: 17 Jul 2013, 10:36
Location: Downhill

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by Nockya »

I am glad you all understood the question so far :cheers:



User avatar
Little General
Sunderland Supporter
Sunderland Supporter
Posts: 19
Joined: 24 Nov 2013, 04:58
Location: Chilton Moor

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by Little General »

Me and the lads will celebrate promotion this year without doubt. Now then would the trophy have been a better celebration ......... hmmmmmm let me think. Well, we celebrate every Sunderland win :lol:
Go on then I think we would have an extra pint or two had we won the tinpot cup :lol:
I think that we will still go overboard when promotion is confirmed though.



cam
Freedom of the City
Freedom of the City
Posts: 2075
Joined: 27 Nov 2013, 06:34
Location: Pallion

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by cam »

Good question since you avoid saying which is the best to have - cup or promotion. Party-wise - the cup. Satisfaction-wise - promotion. So for a party it would have been the Checkatrade tinpot thing :lol:


I might have the day off today!

User avatar
thingamajig
Freedom of the City
Freedom of the City
Posts: 2806
Joined: 18 Jul 2013, 18:10
Location: Southwick

Re: Checkatrade Trophy or Promotion Celebrations - Poll

Post by thingamajig »

This season has had us biting finger nails and nervous through whole matches even though we've only lost two all season.
Promotion is a must but I agree we have had a massive party already without winning the trophy so what would have happened had we won it :o
I voted for the trophy but I repeat that promotion is a must.


What was that you said again?

Post Reply