Wearside Online and Sunderland Forum - Your Local Community

Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

This is the SAFC Forum. You may chat about Sunderland AFC here together with any other footballing matters. Obviously, the Black Cats are the main focus. However, this is basically our football lounge.
User avatar
Gibsy
Local Councillor
Local Councillor
Posts: 420
Joined: 02 Dec 2013, 13:42
Location: Seaham

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by Gibsy »

Zook wrote:
13 May 2019, 00:40
it was a reckless challenge
Nah, 50/50 ball and he won the ball, no contact with opposing player. Their player should have took a yellow card.



User avatar
Stokoe
Sunderland Supporter
Sunderland Supporter
Posts: 305
Joined: 17 Jul 2013, 09:32
Location: Town End Farm

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by Stokoe »

Zook wrote:
13 May 2019, 00:40
Gibsy wrote:
12 May 2019, 17:58
I can't see a red card in all that. There was no intent and both players went for the ball.
And "if" it was at the other end.... Would you say it was then maybe.... Can't fault the ref, it was a reckless challenge, forced into maybe but reckless none the less... I'll be amazed if its overturned...
I am not a betting man but if there is an appeal in, the lad will win this one.


The track suit manager

Zook
Village Idiot
Village Idiot
Posts: 670
Joined: 29 Nov 2017, 17:47
Location: Guidepost, Northumberland

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by Zook »

Gibsy wrote:
13 May 2019, 02:21
Zook wrote:
13 May 2019, 00:40
it was a reckless challenge
Nah, 50/50 ball and he won the ball, no contact with opposing player. Their player should have took a yellow card.
Look at it again... Ozturk goes to ground... Does the Portsmouth player.. 🤔



Zook
Village Idiot
Village Idiot
Posts: 670
Joined: 29 Nov 2017, 17:47
Location: Guidepost, Northumberland

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by Zook »

Stokoe wrote:
13 May 2019, 12:09
Zook wrote:
13 May 2019, 00:40


And "if" it was at the other end.... Would you say it was then maybe.... Can't fault the ref, it was a reckless challenge, forced into maybe but reckless none the less... I'll be amazed if its overturned...
I am not a betting man but if there is an appeal in, the lad will win this one.

If the panel decides in our favour great, I'll stand corrected. It's just my opinion. I still say most of the supporters would be saying "definitely a sending off" if it was at the other end... I try and say things as I see them, not specifically what I want them to be.



User avatar
Jools
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 946
Joined: 16 Jul 2013, 14:25
Location: Silksworth

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by Jools »

Zook wrote:
13 May 2019, 14:43
Gibsy wrote:
13 May 2019, 02:21


Nah, 50/50 ball and he won the ball, no contact with opposing player. Their player should have took a yellow card.
Look at it again... Ozturk goes to ground... Does the Portsmouth player.. 🤔
Is this always a deciding factor?
Never gave it much thought in the past.


I Love Sunderland
I Love SAFC
I Love Wearside

User avatar
Gibsy
Local Councillor
Local Councillor
Posts: 420
Joined: 02 Dec 2013, 13:42
Location: Seaham

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by Gibsy »

Zook wrote:
13 May 2019, 14:43
Gibsy wrote:
13 May 2019, 02:21


Nah, 50/50 ball and he won the ball, no contact with opposing player. Their player should have took a yellow card.
Look at it again... Ozturk goes to ground... Does the Portsmouth player.. 🤔
I did and see a fair challenge of the ball we got there first the Pompey player should have been sent off for diving anyway the panel thinks like most others and have overturned the red card



User avatar
Jenky
Local MP
Local MP
Posts: 880
Joined: 20 Jul 2013, 12:23
Location: Southwick

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by Jenky »

It was never a red card :head-banger:

The Pompey player should have been sent off for making meal of it.



User avatar
thingamajig
Freedom of the City
Freedom of the City
Posts: 2710
Joined: 18 Jul 2013, 18:10
Location: Southwick

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by thingamajig »

Jools wrote:
13 May 2019, 17:15
Zook wrote:
13 May 2019, 14:43


Look at it again... Ozturk goes to ground... Does the Portsmouth player.. 🤔
Is this always a deciding factor?
The referee in this case thought so but then again the referee's rule book is as thick as war and peace.
I never thought it was a red card incident from when I saw it on the day.
Just because an opposing player falls over its not automatically a foul or penalty etc.


What was that you said again?

Zook
Village Idiot
Village Idiot
Posts: 670
Joined: 29 Nov 2017, 17:47
Location: Guidepost, Northumberland

Re: Sunderland v Portsmouth Play Offs First Leg

Post by Zook »

thingamajig wrote:
13 May 2019, 23:31
Jools wrote:
13 May 2019, 17:15


Is this always a deciding factor?
The referee in this case thought so but then again the referee's rule book is as thick as war and peace.
I never thought it was a red card incident from when I saw it on the day.
Just because an opposing player falls over its not automatically a foul or penalty etc.
Obviously not. I stand corrected. I am surprised however.



Post Reply